In my search for the arms presented to the heralds at the Visitations and marked as "respited", whatever arms were presented by Bonne of Burton-on-Trent are going to have to remain a mystery, at least for now.
Bonne of Burton-on-Trent. Offlow Hundred.
"Respite for proofe, etc., but no proofe made."
No published heraldic or genealogical source records a coat of arms for the Bonne family of Burton-on-Trent. Because Peter Bonne failed to produce evidence of his armorial right after being granted a respite in July 1664, no blazon or tricked shield was ever entered in the official College of Arms registers or in subsequent county histories.
In Sir William Dugdale’s Visitation (edited by H. Sydney Grazebrook in Collections for a History of Staffordshire, Vol. V, Part 2), the pedigree was certified at Lichfield in July 1664 by Peter Bonne of Burton-super-Trent (then aged 40), son of Guydo Bonne of Barnham, co. Norfolk (who died in 1639, aged 50). No arms or crest are recorded under the pedigree. In the Harleian Society’s Staffordshire Pedigrees (Vol. 63), Lancaster Herald Gregory King, who accompanied Dugdale as his clerk in 1663–64 and habitually sketched ("tricked") the arms beside family pedigrees, left the shield space blank and explicitly noted: "Proof [of Arms] respited [none exhibited]". The contemporary copy of the arms taken during the 1663–64 Visitation (British Library, Lansdowne MS. 857) lists Peter Bonne's descent from Guido Bonne of Barnham, Norfolk, without recording any blazon.
Unlike families who were formally "disclaimed" (publicly stripped of the title of gentleman), a "Respite for proofe" meant the claimant asserted gentry status, often on the strength of a distant origin, such as Norfolk, but could not immediately produce a patent, grant, or ancient seal.
I have failed to find any later record: Standard Victorian armories such as Burke’s General Armory and William Berry’s Encyclopaedia Heraldica do not list any arms for Bonne of Staffordshire or Norfolk. Because Peter Bonne’s siblings (William and Bridget) appear to have died without issue and no further generations were recorded in Staffordshire, the line left no known monumental brasses or hatchments in the county.
There may however, still be unpublished surviving evidence but this is a depth that I sadly don't have the time to explore. If Peter Bonne used an unofficial seal or signet ring in daily life, it would only appear on original 17th-century manuscript documents rather than printed heraldic books. Archival records show Peter Bonne acting as an agent for the Commissioners for Sequestrations in 1659 (such as a bond preserved in the Derbyshire Record Office under reference D1232/O/94) and appearing as a plaintiff in Chancery proceedings in 1670 (C 78/1559, no. 8 at The National Archives). Examining the physical wax impressions attached to his surviving deeds, bonds, or probate records (if any exist in Lichfield or Prerogative Court of Canterbury wills) is the only way to see if he used an armorial seal.
Tracing his father, Guido (or Guy) Bonne of Barnham, Norfolk (d. 1639), in Norfolk Archdeaconry or Norwich Consistory Court wills via the Norfolk Record Office could reveal whether the family were minor yeomen/merchants who assumed arms upon rising in status during the Interregnum, or if they held an older East Anglian seal.
There is no entry for the exact spelling "Bonne" in Sir Bernard Burke’s General Armory, and no arms are recorded for the Bonne family of Staffordshire or Norfolk. However, standard 19th-century armories, including Burke’s General Armory and William Berry’s Encyclopaedia Heraldica, do record arms under close phonetic variants (Bone, Boon, Boone, and Bohun), which is likely what Peter Bonne was attempting to claim in 1664.
In 17th-century England, surnames were spelled phonetically, and families rising in status frequently claimed descent from older armigerous houses with similar-sounding names. None of the entries below are attributed to Staffordshire or Norfolk, nor can they be assumed to belong to Peter Bonne without proof:
• William Berry’s Encyclopaedia Heraldica (1828–40): Lists "Bonne" strictly as a cross-reference ("Bonne. The same as the first Bone in the first Dictionary"), redirecting the reader to Bone (Ermine, on a cross Gules five bezants).
• Burke’s General Armory (1884): Bone / Boon: Lists Argent, on a bend Azure three fleurs-de-lis Or (Crest: A sword and key in saltire proper) under "Bone, or Boon" without a county location.
• Burke’s General Armory & Berry: Boon / Boone: Lists Azure, on a bend Argent cottised Or, between two lions rampant of the second, three escallops gules (Crest: A hand holding a sheaf of arrows, points downwards, proper). This is a differenced version of the ancient Bohun arms.
• Bohun (Suffolk & Lincolnshire): Because Norfolk and Suffolk share a border, Barnham, Norfolk (where Peter Bonne’s father Guido lived) sits directly on the Suffolk border near Thetford, it is notable that Burke records Bohun of Fressingfield, Suffolk (Gules, a crescent Ermine within an orle of eight martlets Or) and Bohun, or Boone of Lincoln (Azure, on a bend Argent cottised Or, between six lions rampant Gold, three escallops Gules). In East Anglian deeds, Bohun was routinely spelled Boun, Boon, and Bowne.
In all of this, I haven't even touched upon Continental "Bonne" entries. Searching international armories such as Johannes Rietstap’s Armorial Général, there are several coats of arms appearing under the spelling Bonne (such as Bonne de Lesdiguières in Dauphiné or Bonne in Flanders and France). Unless Guido Bonne of Barnham was a Huguenot or Walloon immigrant to East Anglia, a distinct possibility given the large 16th- and 17th-century Continental Protestant settlements in Norfolk, these French and Low Countries arms have no connection to the Burton-on-Trent family.
None of the aformentioned arms can be attributed to Peter Bonne. Under English heraldic rules, a coat of arms belongs strictly to a specific grantee and their direct male-line descendants, never to a surname as a whole. When Peter Bonne appeared before Sir William Dugdale at Lichfield in July 1664, he likely asserted a connection to one of these Boon/Bohun/Bone lines (or to a Continental Bonne family). Because he never returned to the College of Arms with a pedigree or seal proving that link, the heralds refused to assign any of those coats to him.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Please keep your comments relevant, heraldic, and of course civil.