Continuing to explore why it might be that some Staffordshire arms were respited during the Visitations, today I am exploring, and illustrating, the arms of Best of Perry Hall, Offlow Hundred.
Arms: Sable, semee of cross-crosslets Argent, a cinquefoil Or; a mullet for difference.
"Respite given for proofe of these arms, but no proofe made."
Best purchased Perry Hall, Handsworth, from the Stamford family. Shaw says he was a bookseller at Grey's Inn gate.
The detail quoted above comes directly from the 1663–1664 Heraldic Visitation of Staffordshire conducted by Sir William Dugdale (Norroy King of Arms), as published and annotated by H. Sydney Grazebrook in Collections for a History of Staffordshire (Vol. V, Part II, 1884) and Gregory King's Staffordshire Pedigrees (Harleian Society, 1912). The subject of the entry is Richard Best (born circa 1613/14, aged 50 at the time of the Visitation), a wealthy London stationer and Parliamentarian excise official who acquired substantial estates in Staffordshire during the Interregnum.
As noted by Staffordshire historian Stebbing Shaw (and earlier antiquarian Sir Simon Degge), Richard Best began his career as a stationer and bookseller at Gray's Inn Gate in London. He was active in publishing legal and political tracts during the 1640s (including works such as The Office and Duty of Executors in 1641). During the English Civil War and Commonwealth period, he became a "Farmer of the Excise to the Rebels" (a tax collector/contractor for Parliament). This role generated immense wealth, enabling him to buy up estates from Royalist and gentry families in the Midlands. Around 1657, Best built a large, grand brick mansion on the Dean's land near St Peter's Church in Wolverhampton, complete with a walled orchard and garden. This building later became known as the Deanery Hall.
In 1658–1659, Richard Best purchased Perry Hall (in Perry Barr, within the parish of Handsworth and Offlow Hundred) as well as a moiety (half-share) of the Manor of Handsworth from Edward Stanford (spelled Stamford in several Visitation records) but he did not hold the estates for long after the Restoration. In 1670–1671, he sold Perry Hall and his share of the Perry Barr/Handsworth estate to Sir Henry Gough (whose descendants held Perry Hall until its demolition in 1927). In 1679, his son Richard sold the remaining Handsworth manorial rights to Humphrey Wyrley.
In Dugdale's Visitation, Richard Best claimed descent from a Yorkshire gentry family. He recorded himself as the fourth son of Cuthbert Best of Appleton-upon-Wiske in Yorkshire (and grandson of John Best of Appleton). His elder brothers included William Best of Appleton, Cuthbert Best (who served as Governor of the garrison of York), and James Best of Appleton.
The Arms: Sable, semée of cross-crosslets Argent, a cinquefoil Or; a mullet for difference (the mullet indicating a third or cadet branch).
During the Heralds' Visitations, newly wealthy merchants and officials ("new gentry") frequently presented coats of arms they claimed by descent from distant county families, in Best's case, the Bests of Appleton, Yorkshire. Because Best could not immediately produce documentary evidence connecting his London/Staffordshire branch to the armigerous Yorkshire pedigree, Dugdale granted a "respite" (a temporary grace period to submit proof to the College of Arms). No proof was ever submitted, meaning the arms remained officially unconfirmed.
By the time King surveyed the county for Plot’s map in 1680–1682, Richard Best had already sold Perry Hall (in 1670–1671) to Sir Henry Gough (whose arms are featured on Plot's map) and sold the remaining Handsworth manorial rights (in 1679) to Humphrey Wyrley. On the map itself, Perry Hall is marked under the Gough ownership rather than Best.
In College of Arms procedure, a "respite" meant the claimant could not legally bear the arms unless proof was submitted at the next Earl Marshal's court or London term. Because 1663–1664 was the last Heraldic Visitation of Staffordshire (the practice ended nationwide in the 1680s), the respite was never cleared. Following the sale of Perry Hall and Handsworth, the Best family ceased to hold major manorial status in Offlow Hundred. Richard Best the younger (styled "of Walsall" in 1680) and his brothers moved into urban/mercantile or minor parish circles (such as Wolverhampton, Walsall, and London) rather than establishing a new landed seat. When Gregory King later compiled his private genealogical notes (Staffordshire Pedigrees, published by the Harleian Society) and when H. Sydney Grazebrook compiled The Heraldry of Staffordshire (1884), the Best arms were recorded strictly as an unverified claim from the 1663 Visitation, with no subsequent monuments, seals, or sheriff/magistrate rolls showing the family bearing the Yorkshire cinquefoil arms in Staffordshire.
The arms themselves (Sable, semée of cross-crosslets Argent, a cinquefoil Or) remained valid for the Best family of Appleton-upon-Wiske (and later Elmswell) in Yorkshire, from whom Richard Best had claimed descent without documentary proof.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Please keep your comments relevant, heraldic, and of course civil.