Continuing to explore why it might be that some Staffordshire arms were respited during the Visitations, today I am exploring, and illustrating, the arms of Barnfield of Dunston, Pirehill Hundred.
Arms: Or, on a bend Gules three mullets Argent, in the sinister chief an annulet Sable.
"Respite taken for proofe of this cote, but nothing done."
Documentary evidence for the Barnfield family of Dunston (a township in the ancient parish of Penkridge, Staffordshire) is sparse in published gentry pedigrees, which directly reflects why Sir William Dugdale respited their arms during the 1663–1664 Visitation. Because they were a minor, likely cadet branch of the armigerous Shropshire/Devonshire Barnfields/Bamfields, their paper trail survives primarily in cross-referenced gentry pedigrees, local parish and probate records, and collateral Shropshire heraldic grants.
The primary record of their armorial claim is in Sir William Dugdale’s Visitation (published in Collections for a History of Staffordshire, Vol. 5, Part 2). Dugdale recorded a short pedigree for Barnfield of Dunston along with the blazon (Or, on a bend Gules three mullets Argent, in the sinister chief an annulet Sable), noting that a respite was taken to prove the coat, "but nothing done."
The Dunston Barnfields appear as a marriage connection in other Staffordshire visitation pedigrees. Specifically, the pedigree of Coleire of Darlaston records that Margaret Coleire married (? Sampson) Barnfield of Dunston.
The undifferenced coat (Or, on a bend Gules three mullets Argent) is the ancient arms of Bamfield of Poltimore, Devon. On 18 May 1604, these arms were formally confirmed to Robert Barnfield of Edgmond, Shropshire (just across the county border near Newport, roughly 12 miles from Dunston) as a kinsman of Sir Amyas Bamfield of Poltimore. The annulet Sable (the traditional cadency mark for a fifth son) borne by the Dunston branch indicates they claimed descent as a junior offshoot of this Shropshire line, though they failed to produce the documentary deeds or certificates to prove the exact link to Dugdale in 1663–64. Because the family failed to formalise their gentry status at the Visitation, further documentary evidence of their landholdings and lineage is found in local ecclesiastical and civil records rather than College of Arms rolls:
Dunston was a chapelry within the ancient parish of Penkridge. Baptisms, marriages, and burials for the Barnfields of Dunston are recorded in the St Michael and All Angels (Penkridge) parish registers, which date from the late 16th century. Staffordshire fell under the Diocese of Lichfield. Wills, administrations, and probate inventories for the Barnfields of Dunston/Penkridge from the 16th to 18th centuries are held at the Staffordshire History Centre in Stafford. Probate inventories are particularly useful for establishing whether family members styled themselves as gentleman or yeoman after the 1664 respite.
Taken just two years after Dugdale's visitation, the Hearth Tax returns for Cuttlestone Hundred (which includes Dunston and Penkridge) list householders and the size of their dwellings, confirming the family's local standing and residence in Dunston during the exact period of the Visitation.
Burke's lists two coats for Bamfield, both of which are of interest to our search for reasons behind the respiting of the arms of Barnfield of Dunston. The first is for Bamfield: Or, on a bend Gules three mullets Argent. Crest: A lion's head erased Sable crowned Or. The second one gives us more detail: Bamfield (Camden's Grants). Same as last, mullets pierced and in centre chief point an annulet Sable, the Crest charged with an annulet Or.
Looking at this Camden grant, it is an earlier (1604) grant that actually explains where the Dunston Barnfields got their coat of arms in the first place. Camden's grant predates the Dunston Visitation record. William Camden served as Clarenceux King of Arms from 1597 until his death in 1623. Any grant recorded in Camden's Grants was issued at least 40 years before Sir William Dugdale’s 1663–64 Staffordshire Visitation. College of Arms records (specifically Camden's Dockets, Vol. I) document a patent of arms dated 18 May 1604 to Robert Barnfield (or Bamfield) of Edgmond, Shropshire, who was recognized as a kinsman of Sir Amyas Bamfield of Poltimore, Devon. Because the surname was spelled interchangeably as Barnfield and Bamfield in 17th-century records, Burke catalogued this 1604 Shropshire/Devon patent under Bamfield.
But how does the Dunston family connect to the 1604 Grant since there is clearly a similarity in the arms they used?
The 1663–64 Staffordshire Visitation (along with Gregory King’s 1680–1700 continuation in Staffordshire Pedigrees) reveals the exact lineage of Thomas Barnfield of Wolverhampton and Dunston (aged 39 in 1663). His grandfather is shown as Robert Barnfield of Newport, Shropshire (adjacent to Edgmond). His father is recorded as Richard Barnfield of Wolverhampton (died 1644), the second son of Robert Barnfield of Newport. Thomas Barnfield at Dunston (died c. 1680), the third son of Richard Barnfield of Wolverhampton. He married three times: (1) Grace Bohey of Colton, (2) Dorothy Fleetwood (daughter of Sir Richard Fleetwood, 1st Bart. of Calwich), and (3) Mary Anson of Dunston.
So, why did Dugdale respite the arms in his1663–64 Visitations?
Because Thomas Barnfield was a younger son of a younger branch living across the county border in Staffordshire, he presented a slightly garbled version of the 1604 Shropshire family coat (shifting the annulet to sinister chief and omitting the piercing on the mullets). Having neither the original 1604 vellum patent (which most likely stayed with the senior Shropshire line) nor a certified pedigree linking his grandfather in Newport to Robert Barnfield of Edgmond, Dugdale marked the arms "Respite taken for proofe of this cote, but nothing done" and Gregory King later annotated the pedigree "Intr. Not proved".
The Dunston family did not obtain a new grant or change their name to Bamfield; rather, the male line appears to have declined or died out locally within two generations. Sampson Barnfield (Thomas’s eldest son by his first wife, aged 9 in 1663) married Mary Hickin of Dunston and was living at nearby Rickerscote (Castle Church parish, just south of Stafford) around 1679, but had no children by 1680. James Barnfield (aged 4 in 1663) and Thomas Barnfield (aged c. 14 in 1680) were Thomas’s younger sons by his second and third marriages. A comprehensive summary of this exact pedigree is published in Staffordshire Pedigrees Based on the Visitation of that County Made by William Dugdale, 1663–1664 (Harleian Society, Vol. 63, p. 19).


No comments:
Post a Comment
Please keep your comments relevant, heraldic, and of course civil.